Rejection guides / Guideline 4.8: Login Services (Sign in with Apple)
Guideline 4.8 - Design - Login Services, explained
If people can sign in with a third-party or social account, Apple wants an equivalent option that protects their privacy. Sign in with Apple is the usual answer.
"Apps that use a third-party or social login service (such as Facebook Login, Google Sign-In, Log in with X, Sign In with LinkedIn, Login with Amazon, or WeChat Login) to set up or authenticate the user's primary account with the app must also offer as an equivalent option another login service ..."App Review Guideline 4.8, Apple
Get your own rejection explained
Paste the message from App Store Connect or Play Console. Free, no account, about ten seconds.
What the other login service must do
- Limit data collection to the person's name and email address.
- Let the person keep their email address private when setting up the account.
- Not collect interactions with your app for advertising without consent.
These are the three features 4.8 lists. Sign in with Apple has them, which is why most developers add it, but the guideline describes the features rather than naming one service.
When you don't need it
- The app only uses your company's own account setup and sign-in.
- It's an alternative app marketplace, or distributed from one, using a marketplace-specific login.
- It's an education, enterprise or business app that requires an existing education or enterprise account.
- It uses a government or industry-backed citizen ID or electronic ID.
How to fix it
- Add Sign in with Apple, or another service with the three features, as an equal option on the sign-in screen.
- Give it the same prominence as your other social logins, not hidden behind "more options".
- Handle the private relay email address, and don't ask people for their real email straight after they chose to hide it.
- If you believe an exemption applies, say which one in your reply and why.
- Remember that if the app supports Sign in with Apple, account deletion must revoke its tokens (see guideline 5.1.1(v)).
Common questions
- I only offer email and password plus Google. Do I need Sign in with Apple?
- Google Sign-In is a third-party login, so 4.8 asks for an equivalent option with the listed privacy features, unless an exemption applies. Your own email and password login on its own doesn't count as that option.
- Does it have to be Sign in with Apple?
- The guideline lists features rather than a brand. Any login service that meets all three can satisfy it. Sign in with Apple is the most common choice.
Get your own rejection explained
Paste the message from App Store Connect or Play Console. Free, no account, about ten seconds.
Related guides
- Guideline 5.1.1(v): Account sign-in and deletion
- Guideline 5.1.1(i): Privacy policy and permission strings
- Guideline 2.1: Information Needed
Apple decides every review. These guides explain what the guidelines say and what usually helps. They can't promise an approval.
Sources: App Review Guidelines (Apple)